Skip to main content

The Performance Cost of Too Many Checkpoints: Reviewing the Review Process

How to reduce duplicated waiting while preserving the evidence and authority needed for a sound decision.

The Performance Cost of Too Many Checkpoints: Reviewing the Review Process

An operations team wants to purchase a scheduling tool. The request passes through budget approval, security assessment, contract review, and a final committee. Each participant has a legitimate interest. The request still returns twice because reviewers worked from different versions of the proposed service, and the committee asks for information that an earlier reviewer already obtained.

The delay does not establish that the controls are unnecessary or that reviewers are protecting themselves. It shows a process worth examining. Some waiting may be unavoidable while material evidence is gathered. Other waiting may arise from duplicated work, unclear entry requirements, unavailable decision-makers, or an approval route that treats unlike requests identically.

A checkpoint earns its place by making a relevant judgement possible or providing a required control. Assessing the process means understanding that contribution and comparing alternative ways to provide it. The aim is a reliable decision reached with proportionate effort and delay.

State What Each Checkpoint Is There to Establish

Ask each reviewer what they need to determine, what evidence they use, and what authority their response carries. Budget approval establishes a spending commitment. Security assessment examines relevant risks and controls. Contract review considers the proposed obligations. These activities overlap in places but are not interchangeable.

The final committee may make a distinct choice about priorities or accept a material exception. Alternatively, it may simply confirm that all earlier approvals exist. Those are different functions. A checklist or recorded authorisation may be sufficient for the latter, depending on the organisation’s rules.

The US Government Accountability Office’s Green Book places control activities within a system designed to support organisational objectives. It is a federal internal-control framework, rather than a universal procedure for business purchasing. It provides a useful reference for considering the purpose of a control and the responsibilities around it.

Document the purpose before redesigning the step. Otherwise a proposal to remove an apparent duplicate may unintentionally remove an independent judgement or a separation of duties that the organisation still needs. The same exercise can reveal a checkpoint whose original purpose no longer applies.

Trace the Information Alongside the Request

For the scheduling tool, the team should maintain a current account of the intended use, users, data, integration, cost, and supplier arrangement. Reviewers need to know which version they assessed and which changes would require another look.

If the team changes from an internal planning tool to one that stores customer information, earlier conclusions may no longer apply. Reassessment is reasonable because the substance changed. By contrast, repeating the same assessment because the record cannot be found is an avoidable information problem.

Map where the request waited and why. Separate time awaiting a reviewer, time obtaining evidence, time making corrections, and time awaiting final authorisation. A total turnaround figure alone cannot identify which part of the process needs improvement.

Include returned requests and abandoned purchases in the sample. Looking only at approvals that completed smoothly may overlook the cases responsible for most uncertainty and repeated work. Ask the requesting team and reviewers for their account, then compare it with the available record.

Match the Route to the Consequences of the Choice

A purchase that uses an approved supplier and a standard configuration may justify a different route from a novel service with sensitive data or a substantial ongoing commitment. The criteria should describe the relevant differences, rather than rely only on price or the seniority of the requester.

A standard route can use prior assessment when its conditions genuinely apply. That requires clear limits, an owner for the approved pattern, and a way to recognise material changes. Prior approval of one configuration does not automatically cover every later use of the same vendor.

The route for higher-consequence requests may remain detailed. The performance question then concerns timely access to qualified review, clear evidence requirements, and avoidance of unnecessary repetition. A lengthy assessment can be justified where the judgement requires it.

Review the criteria periodically. Supplier arrangements, operating practices, and organisational requirements change. A once-standard purchase may need additional examination, while a repeated exception may reveal an opportunity to design a properly assessed standard option.

Decide Which Reviews Can Proceed Together

Some assessments can begin in parallel once the proposal is sufficiently clear. Security and contract reviewers may be able to identify concerns at the same time, rather than waiting for each earlier stage to finish completely. This can expose important conditions before the team commits to a configuration.

Other work has a real dependency. The contract may need to reflect a security requirement that changes where data is processed. Budget approval may depend on a support cost still under negotiation. Parallel work cannot eliminate a decision whose necessary evidence does not yet exist.

A short early discussion can identify those dependencies. It should establish what each reviewer can assess now, what remains provisional, and which changes need to return. This is more precise than asking everyone to approve simultaneously and leaving inconsistent assumptions to be discovered later.

Government service-delivery governance guidance emphasises timely decisions at an appropriate level with the relevant people. The practical implication here is to connect each judgement to usable evidence and authority. It supports examining the route without assuming that every additional participant adds value.

Give Review Capacity and Exceptions an Operating Arrangement

A checkpoint can be well designed and still become a queue if demand exceeds the available qualified attention. The reviewer may support several departments alongside other responsibilities. Requesting teams need a realistic expectation of when the work can be assessed.

Establish how requests enter, what makes them ready, how priority is set, and who can act when a reviewer is absent. A response expectation should account for the complexity of the request. One promised turnaround for every case may create pressure to issue superficial answers or repeatedly stop the clock.

Urgent cases need an authorised route. Identify who can accept an exception, which evidence remains essential, and what follow-up is required. An exception should change the recorded operating position, rather than depend on an undocumented personal agreement.

The requester should understand the consequences of urgency. Bringing one purchase forward may displace another assessment. If that matters to existing commitments, the priority decision belongs with someone able to make the trade-off. The article on execution bottlenecks examines aggregate demand on shared review capacity.

A reviewer should also be able to return a request with a clear explanation of what is missing. Treating every incomplete submission as fully ready can fill the queue with work that cannot yet be decided. Equally, vague entry requirements can create unnecessary rounds of preparation. Define completeness in terms of the judgement required.

Automate a Defined Check Without Implying a Broader Judgement

Some evidence can be checked consistently by software. A workflow could confirm that a purchase has a valid budget reference, the required fields are present, or a previously approved configuration was selected. That may reduce manual repetition while leaving the underlying spending or risk decision with an authorised person.

State exactly what the automated result establishes. A complete form does not prove the information is accurate. A selected standard configuration does not establish that the actual deployment matches it. The process needs a way to examine relevant discrepancies and return exceptions for judgement.

Treat the automated rule as part of the process that needs maintenance. Identify who can change it, how the intended behaviour is checked, and what happens if the tool is unavailable. Otherwise the organisation may replace a visible human queue with a less visible dependency on an obsolete rule. Automation is useful when it provides the defined check reliably and makes its limits clear to the people relying on the result.

Test Whether Simplification Preserved the Protection

A trial might remove a duplicated committee check for a defined standard purchase while retaining the required budget, security, and contract judgements. Record the conditions and the person authorised to approve the revised route. Changes to formal requirements need the appropriate approval before the trial begins.

Compare waiting, repeated submissions, clarification effort, and the quality of the resulting decision. Check whether reviewers receive the relevant version and whether requesters understand what was approved. A faster process that loses important conditions is not an equivalent service.

Look for work displaced into other channels. Reviewers may now provide informal advice before submission, or requesters may spend longer preparing a larger evidence pack. Include that effort in the comparison rather than declaring success from the formal queue alone.

The organisation should also examine a few difficult cases. A route can appear efficient on routine purchases while lacking a usable response to a material change. Confirm that the exception process works, the right person can decide, and unresolved conditions remain visible.

Finally, assign maintenance of the process. Someone should keep the route, evidence requirements, and delegations current, and remove obsolete guidance when the arrangement changes. Otherwise staff may continue following an old sequence alongside the revised one.

Checkpoint design is part of decision-rights design: people need to distinguish advice, required agreement, and the authority to commit. A well-designed process makes those judgements available with the evidence they require, while avoiding repeated waiting for a decision already made.