A professional services firm announces a strategy focused on growth, specialist expertise, and stronger margins. A department manager then receives three requests: accept a bespoke assignment from a major prospect, release experienced staff for training, and reduce delivery costs this quarter. Each request supports part of the announced direction. They compete for the same people.
The manager can prepare options and make some choices locally. She still needs to know which commitments take precedence, what kind of growth the firm intends to pursue, and which trade-offs she is authorised to make. Without that clarity, the same conflict can return through staffing discussions, sales promises, and performance reviews.
The managerial cost of unclear strategy is therefore more specific than extra meetings. It includes the work required to reconcile incompatible interpretations, prepare plans that later change, and maintain commitments whose assumptions remain unsettled. Some uncertainty is unavoidable. The practical task is to distinguish useful local judgement from an unresolved organisational choice.
Identify the Choice Hidden Behind Broad Goals
Growth, expertise, and margin can all matter. Listing them does not explain how the firm intends to compete or what it will do when they conflict. The manager needs enough direction to choose between plausible actions, rather than infer priorities from the latest request.
Richard Rumelt’s The Perils of Bad Strategy distinguishes a diagnosis, a guiding policy, and coherent actions. It provides a framework for examining whether a strategy addresses a challenge and connects choices. It does not establish that every broad statement is intentionally evasive or that one document can resolve all future decisions.
For the services firm, the relevant challenge might be dependence on low-margin bespoke work that occupies scarce specialists. A guiding approach could focus on repeatable services for a defined client group. Training and commercial decisions would then need to support that approach.
That diagnosis may be wrong, and the firm should test it. The immediate improvement is that managers can discuss a specific interpretation and its consequences. A collection of positive ambitions gives them much less to examine.
Follow the Cost Through Actual Management Work
The department manager builds a staffing plan for the new prospect. The training request changes availability. A finance review then challenges the margin, so the proposal is revised. Sales has already discussed a start date with the client. Several people now need to reopen commitments made under different assumptions.
Some revision is ordinary planning. The concern is repetition caused by a choice that has remained unresolved across several cases. If the firm repeatedly asks whether to prioritise bespoke revenue or capability investment, it may need a portfolio decision rather than better scheduling at department level.
Follow a sample of those cases. Identify the competing instructions, the assumptions each plan used, the time spent preparing and revising it, and the decision that eventually settled the conflict. Include the effects on other work where they can be established.
Avoid assigning a fixed percentage of management time to strategic ambiguity without evidence. The local account may reveal a substantial burden, a limited issue, or a different cause such as inadequate capacity. It should inform the diagnosis rather than serve as a number chosen to support it.
Preserve Discretion Where Local Knowledge Matters
A strategy should not prescribe every staffing decision. The department manager may be better placed to sequence training, match experience to an assignment, or adapt delivery within an agreed offer. Local discretion allows the organisation to use that knowledge.
The boundary becomes clearer when leadership specifies the commitments that matter. The manager might be authorised to accept work within a standard service and resource envelope, while bespoke obligations that displace capability investment require a commercial decision at another level.
This arrangement leaves judgement with the department while making exceptions reviewable. It also distinguishes a strategic choice from an implementation preference. Two managers can use different delivery methods while pursuing the same intended outcome.
Uncertainty about customer demand may justify exploration. A pilot should then state what the firm wants to learn, what resources it will commit, and when the result will be reviewed. Treating an experiment as an unconditional revenue promise can undermine both learning and planning.
Bring a Conflict Back as a Decision With Alternatives
The manager can present the prospect request alongside its effect on training and existing clients. The options might be to offer the standard service, accept a bespoke assignment with additional capacity, delay the start, or decline work outside the intended focus.
Each option should explain the material assumptions, cost, timing, and obligations. A proposal that ignores displaced work asks leadership to compare an apparently free opportunity with a visible investment. Showing the competing commitments gives the decision a more realistic basis.
Ask who can make the choice and when it is needed. If several leaders have different mandates, the route should identify how they resolve disagreement. The manager should not have to obtain informal assent from each person while no one is able to settle the combined trade-off.
A useful decision also states the position while the issue is open. The department may continue existing work while withholding a new client commitment that has not been authorised. The relevant decision rights should make that position clear.
Connect the Answer to Resources and Evaluation
A decision to prioritise specialist capability needs time in the staffing plan. A decision to pursue bespoke growth needs appropriate pricing, expertise, and support. Communication alone will not make the choices coherent if the resource allocation continues to support a different plan.
Performance expectations should reflect the same decision. The manager should not be criticised for declining an assignment that the agreed approach excludes, unless the approach has changed or the application was mistaken. Equally, an agreed exception should not silently become permission for every similar request.
This is where strategy connects with incentive interpretation. Staff observe which commitments receive resources and which choices are rewarded. Managers need to explain the authorised standard, rather than privately guess which public priority leadership will value at review time.
Record material changes and communicate them to the affected people. A staffing decision may need to reach sales, finance, training leads, and existing delivery teams. Without that return path, each group can continue acting on an earlier version of the plan.
A concrete decision might authorise a limited discovery assignment for the prospect while preserving the training allocation. That would create a narrower commitment than accepting the full bespoke engagement. Sales would know what it can offer, the department would know which specialists are available, and the sponsor would know when a further choice is required.
The decision should identify the evidence needed to proceed beyond discovery and who will assess it. If the work reveals an opportunity that changes the original diagnosis, leadership can reconsider the wider approach. This preserves the ability to learn without allowing an exploratory assignment to expand informally into a delivery promise. It also gives the manager a useful stopping point when a new request exceeds the agreed boundary.
Learn From Repeated Exceptions Without Rewriting Direction Daily
An exception can reflect an unusual client opportunity. A pattern of exceptions may indicate that the intended service does not fit demand or that the commercial process keeps promising work the operating model cannot support. Those possibilities require different responses.
Review the evidence at an agreed interval. Compare why exceptions were requested, what happened after approval, and whether they delivered the expected benefit. Avoid treating every difficult case as a reason to abandon the approach or every departure as disloyalty to it.
The manager’s operational knowledge can improve strategy. She may identify that a repeatable service needs a different support package or that training requirements were underestimated. Leadership should have a route for considering that evidence and explaining whether it changes the wider choice.
A clear review point helps the team distinguish a settled commitment from an active question. Continually reopening priorities without acknowledging the cost can leave plans unstable. Refusing to revisit a failing assumption can preserve apparent consistency while results deteriorate.
Assess Whether the Direction Became Easier to Use
Test the clarified approach against several realistic cases before declaring success. Ask different managers which work they would accept, what they would defer, and which decision would require escalation. Differences may reveal a remaining ambiguity worth resolving.
After implementation, examine whether the same priority conflicts recur, how often plans reopen for the same reason, and whether resource commitments follow the agreed direction. Fewer meetings alone are an incomplete measure; the organisation may have reduced discussion while leaving people to make incompatible assumptions.
The broader article on less visible management work explains why this effort should be assessed through its practical consequences. A manager preparing a well-evidenced strategic decision can be adding value. Repeatedly repairing the same unresolved choice is a different use of time.
The aim is direction specific enough to guide consequential choices, with room for local judgement and evidence that challenges the original assumptions. When that arrangement works, managers can spend less effort discovering which promise applies and more effort turning an understood choice into a credible plan.





